Running Back RouletteGet alerts

Page updated

← All windows

Thursday Night · Week 11

First kickoff Thu, Nov 19, 8:15 PM EST · 1 gameboard v2
IND @ HOU8:15 PM EST
Indianapolis Colts
lottery ticketreview needed
Jonathan Taylor
Starter· history rating 35/100
Jonathan Taylor
Seth McGowan
Next man up
Seth McGowanRB2early down11% rostered · likely free

Worth holding: the clear No. 2 with a growing weekly role behind Jonathan Taylor.

Write-up updated Tue, Nov 17, 8:41 AM EST.

64
successor score
Rest of the stableDJ Giddens (RB3)Expand
  • DJ Giddens
    DJ GiddensRB3receiving0% rostered · free long shot

    The demotion is confirmed rather than reversed: Indianapolis' unofficial Week 7 depth chart, released Oct. 20, lists the backs as Jonathan Taylor, Seth McGowan, Giddens, leaving him third with no return role either - McGowan has that too. He still has the most complete backup skill set here, so he stays a plausible lead back if Taylor missed extended time.

    Injury history: No significant reported injury absences since entering the league in 2025; his light usage reflects Jonathan Taylor's workload rather than health. A knee issue surfaced before Week 2 and he was listed questionable, then played. No current injury designation was located this cycle, and missing injury data does not establish health.

    62
    score
Full depth chart & player scouting
Why this pick · the matrix

Evidence: low. Stash priority: 60/100. Scores are rankings, not probabilities.

Rostered in 11% of ESPN leagues when this board was built. Your league may differ; if he is taken, check the rest of the stable for a lower-rostered back.

Depth chart×24
RB2
23.5
Role fit×24
early down
18.8
Talent×18
tier 2/5
4.4
Clear path×18
rivals: DJ Giddens
12.4
Could take the job×12
backup profile
2.4
Own health×6
availability unverified
2.9
Seth McGowan · regular-season history
Regular-season rushing and receiving statistics for Seth McGowan
SeasonGames*CarriesRush ydsTargetsRecRec ydsTD
202610552856592
2025No stats available before this game week

Last 3 games with stats for IND: 7.7 carries and 0.3 targets per game.

*Games with a recorded stat line; not an attendance or injury measure. Stats exclude this game week. Source: nflverse

Jonathan Taylor · regular-season history
Regular-season rushing and receiving statistics for Jonathan Taylor
SeasonGames*CarriesRush ydsTargetsRecRec ydsTD
20261017773940282408
2025173231585554637820

Last 3 games with stats for IND: 12.3 carries and 4.7 targets per game.

*Games with a recorded stat line; not an attendance or injury measure. Stats exclude this game week. Source: nflverse

Verdict: Worth holding (a judgment, not a report). McGowan is the No. 2 on the Colts' unofficial Week 11 depth chart (Nov. 16), ahead of DJ Giddens, and he already has a role of his own: 12 carries for 77 yards and a touchdown in the Nov. 15 win over Miami, both career highs, while Jonathan Taylor had 16 carries for 83 yards on 68 percent of the snaps. The team site attributes Taylor's lighter share to McGowan's emergence rather than the trade deadline, which passed with Taylor staying. If Taylor missed time McGowan would lead the early-down work, with Giddens (two offensive snaps and no touches Sunday; date-only evidence) as the change of pace. Taylor has no reported injury, so the full payoff is a long shot this week, but the stand-alone carries and a clear path make McGowan a hold. No game designations exist yet for Thursday.

Backfield news: Week 10 vs. Miami (Nov. 15, 24-22 win): Taylor 16 carries for 83 yards plus two catches for 20; McGowan 12 for 77 and a touchdown plus two kickoff returns; Giddens two offensive snaps, no touches. Taylor played 68 percent of the snaps with 55 percent of the designed runs, in line with the week before. Shane Steichen praised McGowan's vision and physicality. Unofficial Week 11 depth chart (Nov. 16): Taylor, McGowan, Giddens. No running back injury was reported out of the game. Short week: the Colts play at Houston on Thursday night.

Scouting: Seventh-round rookie who holds the No. 2 job ahead of Giddens and kept it through Week 1, but he remains essentially unused behind Taylor's workload. He would be first up if Giddens' knee sits him, though Indianapolis would more likely spread a committee than hand him a lead role.

Starter injury history: 2024: a high ankle sprain (Week 4 vs. PIT) cost him games; he missed at least three games in each season from 2022 through 2024. 2025: played the full 17-game slate above a 70% snap share in all but one game, with 20 total TD. 2026: handled a full Week 1 workload against Baltimore and carries no designation on Indianapolis' Week 2 injury report (dated 9/18).

Houston Texans
lottery ticketreview needed
David Montgomery
Starter· history rating 72/100
David Montgomery
Emari Demercado
Next man up
Emari DemercadoRB3change of pace0% rostered · free long shot

One-window flier: next up Thursday only if Montgomery can't go; Marks is due back soon.

Write-up updated Tue, Nov 17, 8:41 AM EST.

59
successor score
Full depth chart & player scouting
Why this pick · the matrix

Evidence: low. Stash priority: 62/100. Scores are rankings, not probabilities.

Rostered in under 1% of ESPN leagues when this board was built. Your league may differ; if he is taken, check the rest of the stable for a lower-rostered back.

Depth chart×24
RB3
23.5
Role fit×24
change of pace
9.4
Talent×18
tier 2/5
4.4
Clear path×18
clear path
17.6
Could take the job×12
backup profile
0.9
Own health×6
availability unverified
2.9
Emari Demercado · regular-season history
Regular-season rushing and receiving statistics for Emari Demercado
SeasonGames*CarriesRush ydsTargetsRecRec ydsTD
2026418474270
2025124431220131011

Last 2 games with stats for HOU: 6.5 carries and 2 targets per game.

*Games with a recorded stat line; not an attendance or injury measure. Stats exclude this game week. Source: nflverse

David Montgomery · regular-season history
Regular-season rushing and receiving statistics for David Montgomery
SeasonGames*CarriesRush ydsTargetsRecRec ydsTD
202655213877673
20251715871629241928

Last 3 games with stats for HOU: 8.7 carries and 0.7 targets per game.

*Games with a recorded stat line; not an attendance or injury measure. Stats exclude this game week. Source: nflverse

Verdict: One-window flier (a judgment, not a report). Woody Marks, Houston's lead back, left the Nov. 15 loss at Cleveland with a concussion after 12 carries for 50 yards, and DeMeco Ryans said afterwards he is unlikely to be ready Thursday (date-only evidence for that item). David Montgomery, inactive four straight games with a groin injury, was estimated as a full participant on the Nov. 16 report, so he is the likely fill-in starter, though Ryans was not certain he can play. Demercado took the work after Marks left (7 carries, 16 yards, one catch) ahead of Dare Ogunbowale, so he is next up. He is free almost everywhere and matters only if Montgomery sits or is limited Thursday. Marks' absence looks short, so after this game Demercado is two injuries from a role: drop him then. No game designations exist yet.

Backfield news: Week 10 at Cleveland (Nov. 15, 27-24 loss): Marks started and had 12 carries for 50 yards and a 15-yard catch before a third-quarter concussion; Demercado followed with 7 carries for 16 yards, Ogunbowale one carry. Montgomery (groin) was ruled out Nov. 14 and inactive. Monday's estimated report (Houston did not practice): Marks did not participate, Montgomery full. Ogunbowale was waived Nov. 13 and re-signed to the practice squad Nov. 14 (date-only log entries), so he needs another elevation to dress. Longer term Marks is the back to own; his return date beyond Thursday is unknown.

Scouting: Demoted. After opening as Williams' backup on single-digit snap counts (five carries for 15 yards across Weeks 1-2), he was inactive for Week 3 vs. BAL as a coach's decision with Goodson active instead. Knows OC Klayton Adams' scheme and is reliable in protection, but he is now behind a player Dallas signed in mid-September and is not the next man up.

Starter injury history: 2024: torn MCL Dec. 15 cost the last three regular-season games. Age 29 with a heavy career touch count. 2026: groin in the Week 5 win at Tennessee on Oct. 11; Ryans called him week-to-week Oct. 12. Two games missed as of early November, and he has not practised since - DNP both days of the official Week 9 report and DNP again on the Nov. 11 Week 10 report. No return date published.

Listed starter Woody Marks is Doubtful; David Montgomery steps in.

Explore player handcuff analysis and stats

Never miss a window