Running Back RouletteGet alerts

Page updated

← All windows

Sunday Morning (International) · Week 4

First kickoff Sun, Oct 4, 9:30 AM EDT · 1 gameboard v1
IND @ WAS9:30 AM EDT
Indianapolis Colts
lottery ticketreview needed
Jonathan Taylor
Starter· history rating 35/100
Jonathan Taylor
Seth McGowan
Next man up
Seth McGowanRB2early down1% rostered · free long shot

Next up behind Jonathan Taylor; depth chart RB2.

64
successor score
Rest of the stableDJ Giddens (RB3)Expand
  • DJ Giddens
    DJ GiddensRB3receiving0% rostered · free long shot

    Second-year back with the most complete backup skill set in the room, but he was passed for the No. 2 job by rookie Seth McGowan and is now RB3. Questionable for Week 2 with a knee issue that surfaced Thursday. Still the most plausible lead back if Taylor missed extended time, though the demotion weakens that case.

    Injury history: No significant reported injury absences since entering the league in 2025; his light usage (26 career touches) reflects Taylor's workload, not health. 2026 Week 2: added to the injury report Thursday with a knee issue and did not practice that day, then listed questionable vs. Kansas City (reports dated 9/17 and 9/18). No return timetable stated beyond the game designation.

    62
    score
Full depth chart & player scouting
Why this pick · the matrix

Evidence: low. Stash priority: 60/100. Scores are rankings, not probabilities.

Rostered in 1% of ESPN leagues when this board was built. Your league may differ; if he is taken, check the rest of the stable for a lower-rostered back.

Depth chart×24
RB2
23.5
Role fit×24
early down
18.8
Talent×18
tier 2/5
4.4
Clear path×18
rivals: DJ Giddens
12.4
Could take the job×12
backup profile
2.4
Own health×6
availability unverified
2.9
Seth McGowan · regular-season history
Regular-season rushing and receiving statistics for Seth McGowan
SeasonGames*CarriesRush ydsTargetsRecRec ydsTD
202636141100
2025No stats available before this game week

Last 3 games with stats for IND: 2 carries and 0.3 targets per game.

*Games with a recorded stat line; not an attendance or injury measure. Stats exclude this game week. Source: nflverse

Jonathan Taylor · regular-season history
Regular-season rushing and receiving statistics for Jonathan Taylor
SeasonGames*CarriesRush ydsTargetsRecRec ydsTD
2026366258119674
2025173231585554637820

Last 3 games with stats for IND: 22 carries and 3.7 targets per game.

*Games with a recorded stat line; not an attendance or injury measure. Stats exclude this game week. Source: nflverse

Seth McGowan is listed RB2 on the Indianapolis Colts depth chart behind Jonathan Taylor. Deterministic pick; the model overview was unavailable.

Backfield news: No current injury notes available; availability is not independently confirmed.

Scouting: Seventh-round rookie who holds the No. 2 job ahead of Giddens and kept it through Week 1, but he remains essentially unused behind Taylor's workload. He would be first up if Giddens' knee sits him, though Indianapolis would more likely spread a committee than hand him a lead role.

Starter injury history: 2024: a high ankle sprain (Week 4 vs. PIT) cost him games; he missed at least three games in each season from 2022 through 2024. 2025: played the full 17-game slate above a 70% snap share in all but one game, with 20 total TD. 2026: handled a full Week 1 workload against Baltimore and carries no designation on Indianapolis' Week 2 injury report (dated 9/18).

Analyst write-up pending; deterministic pick shown.

Washington Commanders
lottery ticketreview needed
Jacory Croskey-Merritt
Starter· history rating 45/100
Jacory Croskey-Merritt
Rachaad White
Next man up
Rachaad WhiteRB2receiving67% rostered · if he's free

Next up behind Jacory Croskey-Merritt; depth chart RB2.

72
successor score
Rest of the stableKaytron Allen (RB3)Expand
  • Kaytron Allen
    Kaytron AllenRB3early down1% rostered · free long shot

    Physical rookie sharing the No. 3 spot who fits Washington's stated situational approach on early downs and in short yardage; cleared through a minor hip in Week 3 prep. Real ability, but if Croskey-Merritt sat he would split the work with White rather than take the job over.

    Injury history: Rookie with no prior NFL injury history; healthy through camp and the preseason. 2026: a hip injury appeared on Washington's Week 3 injury report - limited Wednesday, full participant Thursday, and he was not among the players ruled out for Sept. 27. No games missed and no timetable needed.

    58
    score
Full depth chart & player scouting
Why this pick · the matrix

Evidence: low. Stash priority: 68/100. Scores are rankings, not probabilities.

Rostered in 67% of ESPN leagues when this board was built. Your league may differ; if he is taken, check the rest of the stable for a lower-rostered back.

Depth chart×24
RB2
23.5
Role fit×24
receiving
20.0
Talent×18
tier 3/5
8.8
Clear path×18
rivals: Kaytron Allen
12.4
Could take the job×12
backup profile
4.1
Own health×6
availability unverified
2.9
Rachaad White · regular-season history
Regular-season rushing and receiving statistics for Rachaad White
SeasonGames*CarriesRush ydsTargetsRecRec ydsTD
202632210099511
20251713257245402184

Last 3 games with stats for WAS: 7.3 carries and 3 targets per game.

*Games with a recorded stat line; not an attendance or injury measure. Stats exclude this game week. Source: nflverse

Jacory Croskey-Merritt · regular-season history
Regular-season rushing and receiving statistics for Jacory Croskey-Merritt
SeasonGames*CarriesRush ydsTargetsRecRec ydsTD
20263471423351
202517175805139688

Last 3 games with stats for WAS: 15.7 carries and 1 targets per game.

*Games with a recorded stat line; not an attendance or injury measure. Stats exclude this game week. Source: nflverse

Rachaad White is listed RB2 on the Washington Commanders depth chart behind Jacory Croskey-Merritt. Deterministic pick; the model overview was unavailable.

Backfield news: Jeremy McNichols: Out (espn_rosters)

Scouting: Veteran with a 250-touch season on his resume, working as Washington's third-down and passing-game back. Genuinely three-down capable and the clear beneficiary if Croskey-Merritt's soft-tissue problems return - the most reliable handcuff in this room. Jayden Daniels' week-to-week elbow injury may lift backfield targets, though no coach has said so.

Starter injury history: 2025 (rookie): played all 17 games - 175 carries, 805 yards (4.6), 8 TD. 2026 has been rockier: missed OTAs with a soft-tissue injury, day-to-day with a groin in camp, a lower-body injury Aug. 20 that cost the last two preseason games, limited before Week 1. Clean since: absent from the Week 3 injury report (Sept. 23), not among the five ruled out Sept. 27.

Analyst write-up pending; deterministic pick shown.

Explore player handcuff analysis and stats

Never miss a window