Page updated
Eight of nine: what happened when the starter went down
Nine times through Week 9 of the 2026 season, the running back we listed as a team’s starter finished the game with fewer than six touches. In eight of those nine games, the backup we had named before kickoff led that backfield in touches. Two of them were rostered in 1% of leagues at the time.
The nine games
Before every game window we name one back per team as the next man up. This table takes the board exactly as it stood at kickoff and looks only at the games where the listed starter ended up with fewer than six carries plus catches. The roster figure is the share of ESPN public leagues that had the backup going into that game.
| Week | Starter | Our stash | Rostered | His game | Led the backfield |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | Saquon Barkley (PHI, 5 touches) | Tank Bigsby | 15% | 13 carries, 33 yards, 2 catches, 1 TD | Yes |
| 3 | De’Von Achane (MIA, 3 touches) | Ollie Gordon II | 1% | 17 carries, 41 yards, 3 catches, 1 TD | Yes |
| 4 | Jaylen Wright (MIA, 5 touches) | Ollie Gordon II | 62% | 9 carries, 100 yards, 2 catches, 1 TD | Yes |
| 4 | Saquon Barkley (PHI, 3 touches) | Tank Bigsby | 16% | 14 carries, 55 yards | Yes |
| 5 | David Montgomery (HOU, 5 touches) | Woody Marks | 48% | 15 carries, 62 yards, 4 catches, 23 yards | Yes |
| 5 | Alvin Kamara (NO, 5 touches) | Kendre Miller | 12% | 10 carries, 30 yards, 1 TD | Yes |
| 6 | Cam Skattebo (NYG, no stat line) | Najee Harris | 6% | 4 carries, 2 yards | No |
| 8 | Ashton Jeanty (LV, 5 touches) | Mike Washington Jr. | 18% | 25 carries, 83 yards | Yes |
| 9 | Josh Jacobs (GB, 4 touches) | Kaleb Johnson | 1% | 14 carries, 68 yards, 1 TD | Yes |
The miss was Week 6 with the Giants. Cam Skattebo had no rushing or receiving line, our pick Najee Harris carried four times for two yards, and Tyrone Tracy Jr. led the backfield with eight touches and two touchdowns. We had the wrong back; the Giants released Harris two days later.
All eight of the others also count as hits on our track record, which requires 12 or more touches or a touchdown.
The ones that were free
The best case of the season so far is Ollie Gordon II. He was our Miami pick from Week 1, and going into Week 3 he was rostered in 1% of leagues. De’Von Achane finished that game with three touches. Gordon had 20, and scored.
He has led the Dolphins’ backfield ever since. In his next four games he had 100 yards and a touchdown on nine carries, 88 yards and a touchdown on 18 carries, and 103 yards and a touchdown on 25 carries, then 19 carries for 69 yards. A back who cost nothing in Week 3 was a weekly starter by Week 5.
Kaleb Johnson was also at 1% when Josh Jacobs finished Week 9 with four touches; Johnson ran 14 times for 68 yards and a touchdown. Kendre Miller was at 12%, Tank Bigsby at 15% and Mike Washington Jr. at 18% when their turns came. Washington’s was the biggest single workload of the group: 25 carries.
Not all of them were free. Woody Marks was already rostered in about half of leagues when David Montgomery went down in Week 5. Marks has had 15 or more carries in every game he has played since.
The slower version: jobs that changed hands between games
Not every takeover happens mid-game. Sometimes the starter is ruled out during the week and the backup is the starter by Sunday. Through Week 10, the back listed as a team’s starter changed from one board to the next 27 times. In 13 of them, the new starter was the back we had named as the stash the week before.
Braelon Allen is the clearest example. He was our Jets pick behind Breece Hall and was rostered in 14% of leagues in Week 3. Over the next five games he carried 93 times for 504 yards and two touchdowns, including 147 yards in Week 8.
Dameon Pierce was at 2% in Philadelphia in Week 5, then had 16 and 15 touches with a touchdown in each of the next two games. Emanuel Wilson was at 35% in Seattle in Week 3; the following week he had 120 total yards and two touchdowns.
The other 14 changes are a mix. Some were an injured starter returning, which no stash pick can get “right”. Others were plain misses: we named the wrong back in Green Bay twice, and once each in Miami, Philadelphia, Cleveland and with the Giants.
Read this honestly
- Nine games is a small sample. Eight of nine is what happened, not a rate we expect to hold.
- “Fewer than six touches” is our cut-off. The box score does not say why a starter’s day was short. It can be an injury, a benching or a late scratch.
- Most stashes did nothing. About one in four of our picks this season has hit in any given week, because most starters play most games. Every one of them is graded on the track record, misses included.
- Roster percentages are from ESPN public leagues. Your league may differ, and a back who was free in most places may have been taken in yours.
What to do with this
The lesson is not to hold one backup all season and hope. It is that the payoff arrives in a single game, without warning, and goes to whoever already has the back on their bench. By Tuesday he costs a waiver claim or most of a budget. On Sunday morning he cost nothing.
That is the case for rotating one bench slot through the best available stash in each game window. If you are new to the idea, start with what a handcuff is.
Figures cover Weeks 1 to 9 of the 2026 season unless stated. Picks are the board as published before kickoff; box scores come from the nflverse player-stats release. Full methodology.
Get the list before every window.
A free email about 3.5 hours before each game window with the ranked stashes, and the results once the games are final.